EdBlogs

Lost Man Years and The Cost of Misalignment

Lost Man Years and The Cost of Misalignment: Examining Aspirations in the Indian Educational Landscape

Dear Friends and Students

A few days back, one of my friends forwarded the left side of the picture above in the context of market sentiment and fluctuations during this period. After going through this picture deeply, I want to align this with a different perspective. I added something different on the right side now!

Indian competitive examinations are the toughest in the world. UPSC Civil Services Examination selection rate is between 0.1 to 0.3%. The National Defence Academy (NDA) success rate is 0.1%. UCEED (common entrance for Design) success rate is 0.7%. The Joint Entrance Examination (JEE) Advanced for IITs success rate is 1.5%. The Common Admission Test (CAT) success rate is 2%. The National Institute of Design (NID) Entrance success rate is 3%. The Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) success rate is 4%. National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) success rate is 6 to 7%. The Graduate Aptitude Test in Engineering (GATE) success rate is 15-17%. The Chartered Accountant (CA) success rate is 25%. If you think Bollywood or Tollywood's success rate, they are less than 0.01%. This career success would be much tougher than other competitive examinations!! This data might vary here and there but the intention is to showcase the shrewdness of the competition.

In a country of 140 crores population, if there is a small mistake in the preparation or aspirational mismatch, it costs heavily. More than to the individual, it costs the Nation’s aspiration and economy. If one student wrongly makes a choice, would cost him a minimum of 2-man years of effort loss. E.g. this year 11,70,000 students prepared for JEE for 2 years. We all know only 1.5% of them would go to IITs. The rest of the 98%, covering 23,00,000-man years of the effort is futile. Assume 10,00,000-man years go for genuine learning, useful in future applications and individual learning. The rest of the 13,00,000-man years of wrong selection of aspiration is completely lost!! If you sum up all competitions together, this number would be astronomical. Nearly two dozen students have taken their lives in Kota in the past eight months (The Hindu, 07, Sep 2023). It is because of a misalignment of aspirations or an inability to see beyond this line.

Why this is happening? It is a clear mismatch of knowing our strengths and weaknesses! If one selects a career aspiration based on individual socio-physical-psychological nature or natural intelligence, the same lost man years would become the most productive man years (As shown in right side of the picture), and constructively Nation can capitalize on this. NEP-2020 is all up for this game change.  

1.    A Head Smart student should apply for JEE but not for NID/UCEED!
2.    A Hand Smart student should apply for Skill based job but not for Civil Services
3.    A Heart Smart student should prepare for his/her startup but not for GATE!
4.    A Heel Smart student should prepare for NDA but not a long-sitting office job!

It requires a lot of societal changes and thinking. The left of the picture teaches us a great lesson! We need to identify whether our kids are Giraffe or Rabbit and push them to the “Water Pool of Competition”.

Do You Agree?

Ravi Saripalle


All Comments

Nishanth Varma    1 y ago

I agree to all the points. It's high time we Indians realise about this issue.

  • 2 Likes
  • |
  • Reply
  • Veditha Keerti Rani    1 y ago

    An eye opener to many! I loved how you included practical data to make this issue more concerning and interesting for the reader sir.

  • 3 Likes
  • |
  • Reply
  • You may also like

    • Dr. Ravi Saripalle
      Published 7d+

    Soul Pleasure Vs Societal Pleasure

    Hard to Accept this Definition but Soft to Reject? Soul Pleasure and Pressure Vs Societal Pleasure and Pressure? Read this perspective!Dear Friends and StudentsGustavo Petro, the Mayor of Bogota,

    • Dr. Ravi Saripalle
      Published 7d+

    Preparing Coders for Tomorrow

    "Preparing Coders for Tomorrow: The Evolution of Code Comprehension in Generative AI”! Computer Science Faculty and IT Recruiters' Dilemma!Dear Friends and Students,This article

    • Dr. Ravi Saripalle
      Published 7d+

    Don’t ask for Hike! Ask for Mike

    Is it an End of Great Resignation and welcoming Stagflation or high misery index? Are you Dear to Your Boss? Else, you will end up Dear to your Loss? Don't ask for a Hike! Ask for a Mike!! Read this

    • Mula Lakshmi Prasanna
      Published 7d+

    My Journey through JEE Preparation: Books I Brought and Used

    Introduction:Embarking on the journey of JEE preparation can be both exciting and overwhelming. As a student who went through this experience, I would like to share my insights on the books I brought

    • Dr.Lakshmi Hymavathi.K
      Published 7d+

    Basics are basic!

    Basics are basic!I enjoy myself conversing with my sister’s two daughters who are in their teenage.  They bring in lots of joy, childish blabber, innocent laughter, filmy jokes, surprise,

    • Dr. Ravi Saripalle
      Published 7d+

    Antidote for AI Job Threat!

    Design Thinking is an Antidote for AI Job Threat! Explained with Example! Proposal to Shri Ashwini Vaishnaw ji, Union Minister for Railways for Upper berth Climbing Issue by 11th Grade StudentDear

    • Prasanth
      Published 7d+

    A demonstration of Influencing people without a formal Authority through CORE values

    Recently, I read a book "Project Management for the Unofficial Project Manager" by Suzette Blakemore, Kory Kogon, James Wood. It stresses on the mastery of four foundational behaviours to be

    • The Art of Teaching
      Published 7d+

    Lessons in Perspective: A Tale for Teachers

    As teachers, we often find ourselves anticipating specific answers from our students. But what happens when their responses diverge from our expectations? This story of a young boy and his math teacher

    • VENKATESH PANYAM
      Published 7d+

    Sunflowers Trait

    Dear students when you score low marks or when you fail to get what you want, you may feel bad and want to give up. Wait a minute, don’t lose hope. Talk to your parents, or friends or teachers, and

    • VENKATESH PANYAM
      Published 7d+

    JEE Mains-2019-Physics Analysis

    To succeed in any competitive exam students should know how the questions were framed in the exam. To understand this every teacher recomends the students to solve the previous exam papers.When a student

    • The Art of Teaching
      Published 7d+

    The Power of Relationships in Education

    In the fast-paced world of education, teachers often find themselves juggling lesson plans, assessments, and administrative tasks. However, amidst the hustle, one fundamental truth remains unchanged: education

    • Sandip University
      Published 7d+

    Civil Engineering Course and its Prospects

    What is Civil Engineering?A proper description of Civil Engineering would be: ‘The art of redirecting and using the resources of nature to create convenient structures to sustain the life of man,